Improving sexually transmitted disease management in the private sector: the Jamaica experience.

OBJECTIVES: To improve the quality of sexually transmitted disease (STD) case management in Jamaica by providing comprehensive continuing medical education to private practitioners who manage 60% of all STDs on the island. METHODS: Six half-day STD seminars were presented at 3-4-month intervals and repeated in three separate geographic locations. All Jamaican practitioners received invitations. The subjects were as follows: urethritis, genital ulcer disease, HIV infection, vaginal discharge syndrome, STDs in children and adolescents, and a review seminar. The program effectiveness was evaluated with a written, self-reported pre-test and a telephone post-test that measured changes in clinical management. RESULTS: Six hundred and twenty eight practitioners attended at least one seminar. Comparing pre- versus post-test scores, there were practitioner improvement trends in all four of the general STD management categories: counseling/education (69.8-73.3%; P > 0.05); diagnostics/screening (57.2-71.0%; P= 0.042); treatment (68.3-74.5%; P> 0.05); and knowledge (66.4-83.2%; P= 0.002). Obtaining syphilis serologies during pregnancy rose from 38.3 to 83.8% (P= 0.001), and providing effective treatment for gonorrhea rose from 57.8 to 81.1 % (P= 0.002), but correct responses on treatment for mucopurulent cervicitis at the post-test was a low 32.4%. CONCLUSION: The introduction of continuing medical education for improved STD care targeting private physicians in Jamaica was successful based on high attendance rates and self-reported STD management practices. However, efforts should continue to address the weaknesses found in STD management and counseling and to reach the providers who did not participate. In the global effort to reduce HIV transmission by improving STD care services, continuing education programs that target the private sector can be successful and should be included as a standard activity to improve care and provide a public/private link to STD/HIV control.

PIP: The Jamaican Ministry of Health has estimated that over 60% of all sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) are managed within the private sector, where 800 (66%) of the country's 1200 registered physicians practice. To improve the quality of STD case management provided by these practitioners, the Medical Association of Jamaica organized a series of 6 half-day seminars repeated at 3-4 month intervals in three geographic locations between December 1993 and July 1995. Topics addressed included urethritis, genital ulcer disease, HIV/AIDS, vaginal discharge, pelvic inflammatory disease, and STDs in children and adolescents. A total of 628 private practitioners attended at least one seminar and almost half the physicians attended two or more. Comparisons of scores on a written pretest completed before the seminar and those from a post-test conducted by telephone after the seminar revealed significant improvements in all four general STD management categories: counseling/education, diagnostics/screening, treatment, and knowledge. The proportion of practitioners who obtained syphilis serologies during pregnancy rose from 38.3% to 83.8% and those providing effective treatment for gonorrhea increased from 57.8% to 81.1%. Overall, 96% of practitioners were providing some level of risk-reduction counseling at the time of the post-test and 74% were prescribing correct treatment regimens. Ongoing education and motivation by the national STD control program or the Medical Association are recommended to improve STD case management even further.

Is HIV/STD control in Jamaica making a difference?

OBJECTIVE: To assess the impact of the comprehensive HIV/STD Control Program established in Jamaica since the late 1980s on the HIV/AIDS epidemic. METHODS: AIDS case reports, HIV testing of blood donors, antenatal clinic attenders (ANC), food service workers, sexually transmitted disease (STD) clinic attenders, female prostitutes, homosexuals and other groups were used to monitor the HIV/AIDS epidemic. Primary and secondary syphilis and cases of congenital syphilis were also monitored. National knowledge, attitude and practice (KAP) surveys were conducted in 1988, 1989, 1992, 1994 and 1996. RESULTS: The annual AIDS incidence rate in Jamaica increased only marginally in the past three years from 18.5 per 100000 population to 21.4 in 1997. HIV prevalence in the general population groups tested has been about 1% or less. Among those at high risk, HIV prevalence rates have risen to 6.3% (95% confidence interval 5.0-8.0) in STD clinic attenders, around 10% and 21% in female prostitutes in Kingston and Montego Bay respectively and approximately 30% among homosexuals. Syphilis rates and congenital syphilis cases have declined. The proportion of men aged 15-49 years reporting sex with a non-regular partner declined from 35% in 1994 to 26% in 1996 (P< 0.001). Women ever having used condoms increased from 51% in 1988 to 62.5% in 1992 and 73% in 1994 and 1996 (P< 0.001), while condom use with a non-regular partner increased from 37% in 1992 to 73% in 1996 (P= 0.006). Condom use among men was high over the period: around 81% had ever used condoms and 77% used them with non-regular partners. Gay men, inner-city adults and adolescents aged 12-14 years all reported increases in condom use while condom sales and distribution increased from around 2 million in 1985 to 10 million in 1995. CONCLUSION: HIV/STD control measures appear to have slowed the HIV/AIDS epidemic in Jamaica, however a significant minority of persons continue to have unprotected sex in high risk situations.